Mostrar mensagens com a etiqueta EUA-Il. Mostrar todas as mensagens
Mostrar mensagens com a etiqueta EUA-Il. Mostrar todas as mensagens

26 setembro, 2011

A jogada de Abu Mazen por Uri Avnery


Uri Avnery
September 24, 2011

                                                           Abu Mazen’s Gamble

A WONDERFUL SPEECH. A beautiful speech.

The language expressive and elegant. The arguments clear and convincing. The delivery flawless.

A work of art. The art of hypocrisy. Almost every statement in the passage concerning the Israeli-Palestinian issue was a lie. A blatant lie: the speaker knew it was a lie, and so did the audience.

It was Obama at his best, Obama at his worst.

Being a moral person, he must have felt the urge to vomit. Being a pragmatic person, he knew that he had to do it, if he wanted to be re-elected.

In essence, he sold the fundamental national interests of the United States of America for the chance of a second term.

Not very nice, but that’s politics, OK?

IT MAY be superfluous – almost insulting to the reader – to point out the mendacious details of this rhetorical edifice.

Obama treated the two sides as if they were equal in strength – Israelis and Palestinians, Palestinians and Israelis.

But of the two, it is the Israelis - only they – who suffer and have suffered. Persecution. Exile. Holocaust. An Israeli child threatened by rockets. Surrounded by the hatred of Arab children. So sad.

No Occupation. No settlements. No June 1967 borders. No Naqba. No Palestinian children killed or frightened. It’s the straight right-wing Israeli propaganda line, pure and simple – the terminology, the historical narrative, the argumentation. The music.

The Palestinians, of course, should have a state of their own. Sure, sure. But they must not be pushy. They must not embarrass the US. They must not come to the UN. They must sit with the Israelis, like reasonable people, and work it out with them. The reasonable sheep must sit down with the reasonable wolf and decide what to have for dinner. Foreigners should not interfere.

Obama gave full service. A lady who provides this kind of service generally gets paid in advance. Obama got paid immediately afterwards, within the hour. Netanyahu sat down with him in front of the cameras and gave him enough quotable professions of love and gratitude to last for several election campaigns.

THE TRAGIC hero of this affair is Mahmoud Abbas. A tragic hero, but a hero nonetheless.

Many people may be surprised by this sudden emergence of Abbas as a daring player for high stakes, ready to confront the mighty US.

If Ariel Sharon were to wake up for a moment from his years-long coma, he would faint with amazement. It was he who called Mahmoud Abbas “a plucked chicken”.

Yet for the last few days, Abbas was the center of global attention. World leaders conferred about how to handle him, senior diplomats were eager to convince him of this or that course of action, commentators were guessing what he would do next. His speech before the UN General Assembly was treated as an event of consequence.

Not bad for a chicken, even for one with a full set of feathers.

His emergence as a leader on the world stage is somewhat reminiscent of Anwar Sadat.

When Gamal Abd-al-Nasser unexpectedly died at the age of 52 in 1970 and his official deputy, Sadat, assumed his mantle, all political experts shrugged.

Sadat? Who the hell is that? He was considered a nonentity, an eternal No. 2, one of the least important members of the group of “free officers” that was ruling Egypt.

In Egypt, a land of jokes and jokers, witticisms about him abounded. One concerned the prominent brown mark on his forehead. The official version was that it was the result of much praying, hitting the ground with his forehead. But the real reason, it was told, was that at meetings, after everyone else had spoken, Sadat would get up and try to say something. Nasser would good-naturedly put his finger to his forehead, push him gently down and say: “Sit, Anwar!”  

To the utter amazement of the experts – and especially the Israeli ones – this “nonentity” took a huge gamble by starting the 1973 October War, and proceeded to do something unprecedented in history: going to the capital of an enemy country still officially in a state of war and making peace.

Abbas’ status under Yasser Arafat was not unlike Sadat’s under Nasser. However, Arafat never appointed a deputy. Abbas was one of a group of four or five likely successors. The heir would surely have been Abu Jihad, had he not been killed by Israeli commandoes in front of his wife and children. Another likely candidate, Abu Iyad, was killed by Palestinian terrorists. Abu Mazen (Abbas) was in a way the choice by default.

Such politicians, emerging suddenly from under the shadow of a great leader, generally fall into one of two categories: the eternal frustrated No. 2 or the surprising new leader.

The Bible gives us examples of both kinds. The first was Rehoboam, the son and heir of the great King Solomon, who told his people: “my father chastised you with whips, but I will chastise you with scorpions”. The other kind was represented by Joshua, the heir of Moses. He was no second Moses, but according to the story a great conqueror in his own right.

Modern history tells the sad story of Anthony Eden, the long-suffering No. 2 of Winston Churchill, who commanded little respect. (Mussolini called him, after their first meeting, “a well-tailored idiot.”). Upon assuming power, he tried desperately to equal Churchill and soon embroiled Britain in the 1956 Suez disaster. To the second category belonged Harry Truman, the nobody who succeeded the great Franklin Delano Roosevelt and surprised everybody as a resolute leader.

Abbas looked like belonging to the first kind. Now, suddenly, he is revealed as belonging to the second. The world is treating him with newfound respect. Nearing the end of his career, he made the big gamble.


BUT WAS it wise? Courageous, yes. Daring, yes. But wise?

My answer is: Yes, it was.

Abbas has placed the quest for Palestinian freedom squarely on the international table. For more than a week, Palestine has been the center of international attention. Scores of international statesmen and -women, including the leader of the world’s only superpower, have been busy with Palestine.

For a national movement, that is of the utmost importance. Cynics may ask: “So what did they gain from it?” But cynics are fools. A liberation movement gains from the very fact that the world pays attention, that the media grapple with the problem, that people of conscience all over the world are aroused. It strengthens morale at home and brings the struggle a step nearer its goal.

Oppression shuns the limelight. Occupation, settlements, ethnic cleansing thrive in the shadows. It is the oppressed who need the light of day. Abbas’ move provided it, at least for the time being.


BARACK OBAMA’s miserable performance was a nail in the coffin of America’s status as a superpower. In a way, it was a crime against the United States.

The Arab Spring may have been a last chance for the US to recover its standing in the Middle East. After some hesitation, Obama realized that. He called on Mubarak to go, helped the Libyans against their tyrant, made some noises about Bashar al-Assad. He knows that he has to regain the respect of the Arab masses if he wants to recover some stature in the region, and by extension throughout the world.

Now he has blown it, perhaps forever. No self-respecting Arab will forgive him for plunging his knife into the back of the helpless Palestinians. All the credit the US has tried to gain in the last months in the Arab and the wider Muslim world has been blown away with one puff.

All for reelection.


IT WAS also a crime against Israel.

Israel needs peace. Israel needs to live side by side with the Palestinian people, within the Arab world. Israel cannot rely forever on the unconditional support of the declining United States.

Obama knows this full well. He knows what is good for Israel, even if Netanyahu doesn’t. Yet he has handed the keys of the car to the drunken driver.

The State of Palestine will come into being. This week it was already clear that this is unavoidable. Obama will be forgotten, as will Netanyahu, Lieberman and the whole bunch.

Mahmoud Abbas – Abu Mazen, as the Palestinians call him – will be remembered. The “plucked chicken” is soaring into the sky.

24 setembro, 2011

Sobre Israel e a Palestina, Obama é Rick Perry por MJ Rosenberg

 A opinião de MJ Rosenberg. A ter em conta por todas as razões. 
M.J. Rosenberg is Senior Foreign Policy Fellow at Media Matters Action Network. Previously, he worked on Capitol Hill for various Democratic members of the House and Senate for 15 years. He was also a Clinton political appointee at USAID. In the early 1980s, he was editor of AIPACs weekly newsletter Near East Report. From 1998-2009, he was director of policy at Israel Policy Forum. 
Nota: Rick Perry é um conservador da linha dura, apoiante do lobby sionista. actualmente é o Governador do Texas. Já anunciou a sua candidatura às eleições presidenciais americanas de 2012


MJ Rosenberg's Foreign Policy Matters

On Israel And Palestine, Obama Is Rick Perry
President Barack Obama's speech to the U.N. General Assembly succeeded in making clear why the Palestinians had no other choice but to take their statehood bid to the U.N. and why the United States can no longer pretend to be an "honest broker" in the conflict.
For the first time since the U.N. conferred statehood on Israel 63 years ago, the sitting U.S president told the world body that the United States will back Israel, right or wrong. The president's speech was so one-sided, in fact, that he sounded a lot like Texas Gov. Rick Perry, who gave a similar speech to a group of "pro-Israel" right-wingers one day earlier. Perry is not the president, so his speech was different, except for the motivation, which was same.
Both speeches were standard "pro-Israel" bloviating, but Perry gave his on the campaign trail and not in front of the entire world. (I hesitate to call a speech opposing Palestinian statehood "pro-Israel" when the latest comprehensive poll on the subject says that 70 percent of Israelis say Israel should support the U.N.'s decision if statehood is granted.)
The very best explanation of what Obama did at the United Nations came from Daniel Levy, a Brit who moved to Israel right out of college 18 years ago. Levy's quote appeared on page one of the Washington Post.
"There is virtually no thread of reason running between the way he [Obama] related to the rest of the world and its developments, particularly in the Middle East, and the positions he espoused on Israel-Palestine — a conflict apparently occurring on another planet," said Daniel Levy, co-director of the Middle East Task Force at the New America Foundation. "Palestinian freedoms, rights and self-determination are somehow supposed to be attained without the recourse to leverage, international law or meaningful international support, considered to be necessary and legitimate virtually everywhere else."
Of course, there is one "thread," although it is not of "reason." Every word in Obama's speech was designed not to advance a resolution of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict but to keep single-issue donors and, to a lesser extent, single-issue voters in his camp for the 2012 election. Not a week goes by without the Obama team sending emails out to people it deems Israel voters to remind them of all the wonderful things this president has done for Israel. One recently was dedicated to citing quotes from Prime Minister Netanyahu praising Obama, the first time I can remember that a president sought to validate himself by citing the praise of a foreign leader.
Obama isn't lying about his "pro-Israel" record, however. This administration has been the most one-sided supporter of everything Israel asks for since 1948. There is no competition. Not even George W. Bush comes close.
When the Israelis, following Obama's election, asked Bush to give Israel permission to bomb Iran, he said no, despite his vice president and neoconservative aides pushing the Israeli position hard. Bush also did more than Obama to advance the peace process that the Israeli right hates so much, convening an international summit at Aqaba and being the first president to say, in unambiguous terms, that the United States supports "two states, living side by side in peace and security."
On Israel, Obama is to the right of Bush, to the right of Reagan, and certainly to the right of Clinton. On Israel and Palestine, Barack Obama is Rick Perry.
Of course, Obama's outrageous surrender to Netanyahu still won't impress the Israel-Firsters. They have despised him from day one, for all kinds of reasons, and predictably condemned the speech. Meanwhile, Israel's thuggish far-right foreign minister, Avigdor Lieberman, told reporters that "I am ready to sign on this speech with both hands."
Lieberman is telling the truth — he could have written Obama's speech — and the neocons are lying. But neocons are adherents of the Sen. Mitch McConnell (R-KY) school: They have only one goal, which is to defeat this president. And although privately they celebrate their amazing success at intimidating Obama into submission, publicly they denounce him and send scary emails to senior citizens in Florida and New Jersey warning them that Obama wants to destroy Israel.
But these speeches and love-ins with Netanyahu accomplish nothing for Obama. The single-issue Israel voters and donors (3 percent of the Jewish community) will take their money and votes elsewhere.
And Netanyahu will, working from Jerusalem, do everything he can to help the Republicans win the next election. It's almost funny how these people would exchange the person who is the most "pro-Israel" president ever (looking at it from their "maintain-the-occupation-at-all-costs" vantage point) for an unknown quantity like Perry or Romney. After all, a Republican whose main constituency is Wall Street would likely turn out to approach Israel with more skepticism than Obama does.
But it's a game. Netanyahu and the lobby want to defeat Obama to demonstrate, yet again, who calls the shots on U.S. Middle East policy.
But forget the campaign for a moment — which is what Obama should have done when addressing the U.N. The president's speech was an embarrassing disaster. Since 2009, 1,600 Palestinians (overwhelmingly civilians and over 400 children) have been killed by the Israeli army. Thirteen Israelis have been killed over the same period. Despite that, Obama devoted 120 words of his speech to Israeli suffering (even going so far as to cite the Holocaust) and not one word to Palestinian suffering.
Example: An Australian newspaper reports on a new film about the tragedy of Palestinian women in Gaza (under full Israeli blockade) who are suffering with breast cancer but are not permitted by Israel to leave Gaza for treatment. (They used to go to Israeli hospitals or hospitals in the Arab states and Europe.) Nor does Israel permit the import of the radioactive isotopes used to treat breast cancers. So they die.
One could go on and on about the horrors of the occupation but it won't matter to the politicians who determine U.S. foreign policy. They know which side their bread is buttered on, as Obama demonstrated at the U.N. this week.
But, I'm surprised to say, Obama did Palestinians and the 70 percent of Israelis who support statehood a big favor. By demonstrating that the United States refuses to play the role of "honest broker" and by telling the U.N. that we are Israel and Israel is us, the United States is yielding the role of Middle East peacemaker to others. The French, Turks, Indians, Brazilians, Chinese, South Africans, and Russians don't agree on much. But they do agree on the urgency of the creation of a Palestinian state in the areas occupied in 1967. And they agree that the United States, no longer the superpower it once was, should move over and let countries not fully invested in one side play a more constructive role.
Those who wonder how these "other countries" could exert the leadership the U.S. has abdicated might consider the issue of economics, trade, etc. Israel does not live on an island with the United States. It is part of the world and not even the United States and the $3.5 billion it hands over to Israel each year (no strings attached) can save Israel if the rest of the world says "enough."
Obama has chosen to abdicate. The rest of the world is eager to step up.
And that is why I have no doubt that the state of Palestine was created this week at the United Nations. By opting out, Obama did a tremendous favor to Palestinians and Israelis both. Palestinians will have their fully sovereign, contiguous state.  And the Jewish state of Israel will finally be secure. As Israelis like to say, "yhiyeh tov." Or as Arabs say, "insha'Allah khair." Everything will be fine.
 
Foreign Policy Matters is updated daily. Check us out HERE.

21 setembro, 2011

US right woos Jews over Palestine bid (FT)


Sent: terça-feira, 20 de Setembro de 2011 20:02
Subject: US right woos Jews over Palestine bid





Financial Times
News Alert
20 September 2011




Keyword(s): Tibet or Burma or Palestine
Frequency: Daily at 20:00 London Time
 
September 20, 5:59pm
US right woos Jews over Palestine bid
Barack Obama has not only been managing a global diplomatic tangle between Israel and Palestine at the UN in New York this week. The move has also left the beleaguered president juggling an acutely sensitive domestic issue with ramifications for his re-election.



September 20, 1:22am
Abbas confirms plan to seek UN membership
Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas has told the United Nations secretary-general that he intends to submit an application for membership on Friday and vowed not to be deterred by the storm of international pressure gathering around him.



Advertisement

© THE FINANCIAL TIMES LTD 2011







19 setembro, 2011

Juppé oferece a Abbas uma mão-cheia-de-nada!

A hipocrisia e o desespero não têm limites no tocante à Palestina

Segundo o al-Hayat de hoje, o MNE francês Alain Juppé vai oferecer a  Abbas um plano de compromisso que PERMITA à Autoridade Palestiniana GANHAR o estatuto de observador na ONU em troca de uma promessa de que o Quarteto (EUA-EU-Rússia-ONU), representado pelo Sr. Blair,  aumentará os esforços para reavivar as negociações de paz estagnadas.

Ou seja uma mão cheia de nada.

A obrigação do Quarteto já era forçar as negociações de paz. Que tem feito? Nada! O Sr. Blair viaja e pavoneia-se pelo Médio Oriente à custa do dinheiro dos povos.

A questão é que a ONU tem conciliado com todas as ilegalidades, crimes de guerra e crimes contra a humanidade que Israel tem perpetrado. E Israel  é membro de pleno direito da ONU desde 11 de Maio de 1949.

É com esse estatuto que, ao longo da sua breve história, ocupa, coloniza e anexa territórios da Palestina e é com esse estatuto que oprime, reprime, prende, tortura e assassina os habitantes desses territórios, quer a nível individual, quer a nível de todo um Povo, cometendo crimes de guerra e contra a humanidade que a ONU condena, mas que nada faz para pôr fim, para além de algumas verberações inócuas.

A ONU faz vista grossa e qual catavento roda para onde a empurra o hálito corrompido dos EUA.

18 setembro, 2011

Votação da Palestina na ONU: Há um dever de admitir?


Esta é a tradução de um artigo do Professor Balakrishnan Rajagopal  (é bom que sigam o link para verem a sua biografia) publicado no The Huffington Post no passado dia 16.

A ter em conta. Una leitura das obrigações dos EUA perante o Direito Internacional.

A Autoridade Palestina (AP), apresentará uma petição formal à ONU na próxima semana para a sua admissão. Não está claro se vão apresentar uma petição ao Conselho de Segurança para adesão plena ou à Assembleia Geral para um "estatuto de observador." Parece que os EUA tem a intenção de impedir qualquer das situações, inclusive pelo uso do seu veto. Quero alvitrar que os EUA seriam simultaneamente imprudentes e violariam o direito internacional se optassem por usar o seu veto.


Devo ser o primeiro a afirmar que o reconhecimento de um Estado é diferente da sua admissão à ONU. Um estado pode ser admitido na ONU pelos votos de muitos outros estados, alguns dos quais podem não reconhecer bilateralmente a existência do membro e podem não ter a intenção de estabelecer com ele relações diplomáticas. Existe uma ampla prática internacional para provar isso, que se estende por todo o caminho desde a Liga das Nações. Portanto, mesmo um voto afirmativo dos EUA a favor da admissão da Palestina na ONU não implica o reconhecimento da Palestina como um Estado pelos EUA. Apesar de a Palestina ter declarado a independência em 1988 e ter sido bilateralmente reconhecida por mais de 120 países, o direito internacional não obriga os EUA a reconhecer a Palestina.

Mas o direito internacional obriga os EUA a fazer duas coisas: primeiro, impõe o dever de os EUA não reconhecerem como legal uma situação criada pelo uso ilegal da força ou por outras graves violações das obrigações jus cogens (normas imperativas). Este dever é reconhecido em inúmeras decisões legais válidas, inclusive pela Comissão de Direito Internacional e pelo Tribunal Internacional de Justiça no seu parecer de 2004 sobre a legalidade do “muro” israelita. Isto significa que os EUA não podem reconhecer como legal qualquer aquisição de território por Israel em áreas fora das fronteiras como elas existiam em 1967. Esta foi de facto a posição consistente dos EUA através de muitas Administrações, e constitui a base da fórmula do presidente Barack Obama para uma solução de dois Estados baseada nas fronteiras de 1967


A petição da AP dirigida a ONU é também baseada no reconhecimento das fronteiras de 1967 com Israel, e assim, de facto, reconhecendo o direito de Israel a existir, uma exigência frequente do governo israelita.Na verdade, dizem agora (e é verdade) que o Hamas desaprova a tentativa da AP para forçar uma votação na ONU, precisamente porque quer a Palestina histórica e rejeita as fronteiras de 1967.



Há um segundo dever imposto aos EUA ao abrigo do direito internacional que a maioria dos comentadores tem falhado em notar, até agora. Que é o dos EUA também estar obrigado a apoiar o exercício do direito da Palestina à autodeterminação pelo direito internacional.


Ao contrário do primeiro dever (negativo) acima indicado, que é o dever de não reconhecer actos ilegais, existe um dever concomitante positivo para apoiar actos legais. O principal meio legal para o exercício da auto-determinação é buscar a adesão a organizações internacionais como a ONU. Isto é, precisamente, o que os palestinos estão procurando.

Este dever de apoiar o exercício da autodeterminação tem muitos aspectos - o dever de apoiar a admissão às organizações das quais se é membro, o dever de não impedir a admissão (incluindo através da utilização de veto), e um dever de auxiliar o povo e o governo do novo Estado a cumprir os deveres e propósitos da ONU, incluindo a forma como eles podem salvaguardar todos os direitos humanos e liberdades.

Se os EUA usar o seu veto para bloquear a admissão da Palestina, cujo direito à autodeterminação tem sido afirmado em centenas de resoluções da Assembleia Geral, do Conselho de Segurança e dos organismos de Direitos Humanos, incluindo muitas em que os EUA também votaram a favor, violaria a lei internacional




No mínimo, os EUA estão sob uma obrigação nos termos do direito internacional de não impedir um voto positivo no Conselho de Segurança ou um voto a favor da Palestina na Assembleia Geral. Tal voto - ou a abstenção, conforme o caso – não retirará de maneira nenhuma valor ao reconhecimento legal da Palestina pelos EUA como já indicamos.

Também é imprudente para os EUA não fazer o que é aqui proposto. A votação na Assembleia Geral é certamente para sancionar o estatuto de observador para a Palestina pelo que se diz. (De facto a proposta vai no sentido de membro de pleno direito se se mantiver a posição anunciada pela AP). Qual é então o ganho político na votação contra a admissão, principalmente quando votar a favor só pode reforçar o longo apoio dos EUA para um Estado Palestino, bem como a sua posição sobre as fronteiras de 1967?


Um veto ou um voto negativo na Assembleia Geral, por outro lado, vai enfurecer a opinião pública mundial e a agravar ainda mais os sentimentos negativos contra os EUA em todo o mundo islâmico


A queda política interna pode ser minimizada, apontando para o fato de os EUA não reconhecerem a Palestina, mas que não conseguirem evitar a sua admissão à ONU. Que é a postura correta legal e moral sobre esta questão crítica.

13 setembro, 2011

EUA: A última oportunidade para fazer o que está certo!

Esta é apenas uma das organizações de judeus-americanos que está a favor do reconhecimento do Estado Soberano da Palestina.

E está a pedir-nos uma coisa simples que demonstremos o nosso apoio através de um simples clik.

Está à espera de quê?



Forty-one.

That's the number of times the United States has used its veto in the United Nations Security Council to block efforts to secure Palestinian rights over the last 40 years.

Now the United States and Israel want the Palestinian Authority (PA) to drop its bid for recognition at the United Nations —and if the vote goes to the United Nations Security Council as soon as next week, we think the U.S. might make that veto forty-two.

That's just plain wrong.

Please join 20,000 others in telling U.S. Hillary Clinton and UN Ambassador Susan Rice that the U.S. must NOT veto yet another push for Palestinian rights.

To be sure, the Palestinian Authority bid for UN recognition is complicated. Israel and the United States- and their Jewish institutional backers—say they are opposed because such a move would be "unilateral". But what is more unilateral than a 44-year-long military occupation of another people? And what forum more multilateral than the United Nations? 

Israel and the United States also say the Palestinians should return, instead, to the peace process. But the so-called "peace process" has meant several decades of expanding settlements and illegally confiscated land. 

That said, and despite the emptiness of Israeli and U.S. rhetoric, there are real criticisms of the PA's effort. Palestinian leaders and civil society organizations have raised a number of concerns ranging from questions about the Palestinian Authority itself to the possible negative significance of the UN vote for refugee rights.

As a Jewish-American organization, we know that Palestinians will be the ones who have to figure out their most effective strategies.  

But we also know we need to continue to speak out for one thing everyone agrees upon:
stopping the United States from continuing to play an obstructive role in securing a lasting and just peace.

No matter what happens, the significance of the vote will be dwarfed by what happens the next day. There will still be an occupation. There will still be refugees. There will still be no Palestinian state.

But there will be an extraordinary nonviolent people's movement in Palestine, in Israel, in the United States, everywhere in the world—and we should use the moment to escalate our demands for justice, fairness, and a future for all people in the region.  

Our Palestinian and peace-loving Israeli allies on the ground will need our support more than  ever—and we'll be ready to provide it. 

But for today, let's send the United States a message. The world is watching. USA? What side are you on?

For freedom,
Cecilie Surasky, Deputy Director
Jewish Voice for Peace
empowered by Salsa

12 setembro, 2011

Enquanto Ashton negoceia pela UE, Alemanha torpedeia...

De acordo com informações vinculadas pelo jornal israelita Haaretz enquanto a responsável das Relações Exteriores da UE, Catherine Ashton procurava chegar a um acordo com a Autoridade Palestina para que esta viesse a baixar a sua reinvindicação de ver reconhecida, na próxima AG da ONU, a Palestina como um Estado de pleno direito, para a de ser acolhida como um membro não-permanente, em troca do apoio em bloco dos 27 a esta proposta, o Ministro dos Negócios Estrangeiros da Alemanha, Guido Westerwelle, terá afirmado a Mhamoud Abbas que não apoiaria a proposta de admissão da Palestina na ONU.
 
Por outro lado diz-nos ainda o Haaretz que Ashton estaria a negociar um acordo com os EUA, em que este se absteria de votar e manteria o apoio financeiro aos palestinos  em troca da promessa do presidente palestino Mahmoud Abbas de não levar Israel ao Tribunal Penal Internacional.  
 
(Estranho acordo que só vem confirmar que existiram crimes de guerra e contra a humanidade cometidos pelos governantes de Israel e pelas suas Forças Armadas e Agências, que agora se pretendem branquear. Sem esquecer a responsabilidade primeira dos EUA nesta triste história, ao longo dos últimos 63 anos.)

02 março, 2011

Dividir para conquistar. Gianni Carta entrevista Magid Shihade

Dividir para conquistar
Gianni Carta, 1 de março de 2011 às 10:07h
in CartaCapital


O cientista político Magid Shihade, professor da Universidade de Birzeit, na Cisjordânia, avalia o cenário político na ocupada Palestina após o veto dos EUA à resolução do Conselho de Segurança que condena os contínuos assentamentos israelenses.

Com o apoio de Obama, a estratégia de Israel permanece

Magid Shihade

CartaCapital: Como avaliar o veto dos EUA?

Magid Shihade: É mais uma prova da estratégia israelense, com apoio de Washington: apodere-se de quanto mais terras possíveis para prevenir um Estado palestino soberano e contíguo. E Israel se sente, mais uma vez, poderoso. O objetivo deles é semear uma coletânea de reservas palestinas dominadas por israelenses. Mas esse processo de dispersar e dividir a Palestina remonta a 1948 (quando nasceu Israel). Você não pode, por exemplo, ir de Ramallah a Belém sem passar por uma caterva de barreiras. Até o presidente da Autoridade Palestina, Mahmoud Abbas, tem de obter permissão de Israel para passar por esses check points. Abbas foi domesticado. Ao dividir as terras palestinas, os israelenses obtêm maior controle sobre os palestinos.

CC: E as negociações de paz entre Israel e a Palestina podem ainda
dar em algo?

MS: Agora, até o Fatah (partido de Abbas, dominante na Cisjordânia) não poderá ficar calado diante das regras impostas pelos israelenses em futuras negociações. Como vimos nos últimos 20 anos, quanto maiores são as concessões feitas pelos palestinos maiores são as demandas feitas pelos israelenses. No fim de 2009, os israelenses congelaram, por dez meses, os assentamentos na Cisjordânia e em Jerusalém Leste. Falaram em concessão. Mas que concessão? Segundo o direito internacional, essas terras pertencem aos palestinos. É como se eu pegasse teu maço de cigarros e dissesse: “Talvez eu te dê um cigarro”.

CC: Abbas anunciou eleições gerais em setembro na Palestina. Diz, porém, que sem a participação do Hamas (agremiação com braço armado dominante em Gaza que refuta eleições) não será possível realizá-las…

MS: O pleito dividiria ainda mais o Fatah do Hamas (a dominar o Estreito de Gaza desde sua vitória em eleições democráticas, em janeiro de 2006). E, por tabela, o vácuo entre a Cisjordânia e Gaza se tornaria ainda mais vasto. Portanto, a Autoridade Palestina e o Fatah tiveram de mudar suas estratégias. Lembre-se que essa contenda entre o Hamas e o Fatah foi mantida por Israel e pelos EUA, com a ajuda de Hosni Mubarak. E voltamos para o tema “dividir para conquistar”. Mas, com a falta de credibilidade de Abbas e da Autoridade, o Fatah teme a imagem ruim dos partidos dominantes na Tunísia e no Egito. Para não serem depostos quando as revoltas mais contundentes chegarem à Cisjordânia, o Fatah e o Hamas têm de se unir, sob a liderança da Autoridade Palestina.

CC: Mas o Hamas é tido como movimento terrorista por, entre outros, Israel e Estados Unidos…

MS: Não tenho nenhuma afiliação com o Hamas, sou um professor. Mas o Hamas, movimento de resistência, não reconhece Israel baseado na raça do povo judaico. Se os israelenses são ou não judeus não é a questão: o Hamas luta pelo direito de retorno de palestinos expulsos de suas terras, em 1948. E por que o Hamas não pode existir se Avigdor Lieberman (ministro israelense do Exterior) fala abertamente na expulsão de palestinos que vivem em Israel para a Palestina? Enquanto isso, a agremiação ultraortodoxa Shas justifica assassinar palestinos. E árabes-israelenses, para obter cidadania, têm de reconhecer Israel como Estado judeu. Mas esses árabes não são judeus e nasceram naquilo que agora se chama Israel. Não é discriminação? Enquanto isso, os israelenses continuam a colonizar os territórios palestinos. A supremacia do judeu sobre o não-judeu, construída pela narrativa sionista, é o maior obstáculo.

Gianni Carta é jornalista, correspondente de CartaCapital em Paris, escreve sobre coisas da vida do Hemisfério Norte.

22 fevereiro, 2011

Sabbah Report

Link to Sabbah Report


Posted: 20 Feb 2011 12:03 PM PST
Of course this American veto is not some idiosyncratic whim, but is an expression of the sorry pro-Israeli realities of domestic politics, suggesting that it is Israel that is the real holder of the veto in this situation, and the U.S. Congress and the Israeli Lobby are merely designated as the enforcers.
Posted: 20 Feb 2011 11:10 AM PST
The resolution had over120 cosponsors (just about the entire non-Western world) and the support of every other member of the Security Council. The only thing wrong with it was that it singled out the Israelis as the culprits and was thus anathema to the politicians in Washington. For the Obama administration, it was a supremely embarrassing moment.
Posted: 20 Feb 2011 10:14 AM PST
Never before has an American President's fear of offending the Zionist lobby and its stooges in Congress been so exposed as it was by Obama's decision to veto the Security Council resolution condemning continued, illegal Israeli settlement activities on the occupied West Bank and demanding that Israel "immediately and completely cease" all such activities. In a different America – an informed America – some might think, I do, that Obama should be impeached. The charge? TREASON.
Posted: 20 Feb 2011 08:58 AM PST
On February 18, as expected, Washington vetoed a UN Security Council resolution condemning Israeli settlements as illegal under international law. The vote: 14 yes, America the sole no, isolating the US and Israel on this long festering issue. The measure had nearly 120 co-sponsors.


21 fevereiro, 2011

With settlement resolution veto, Obama has joined Likud



An America that understands that the settlements are the obstacle should have joined in condemning them.

By Gideon Levy

This weekend, a new member enrolled in Likud - and not just in the ruling party, but in its most hawkish wing. Located somewhere between Tzipi Hotovely and Danny Danon, U.S. President Barack Obama bypassed Dan Meridor and Michael Eitan on the right and weakened their position.

The first veto cast by the United States during Obama's term, a veto he promised in vain not to use as his predecessors did, was a veto against the chance and promise of change, a veto against hope. This is a veto that is not friendly to Israel; it supports the settlers and the Israeli right, and them alone.

The excuses of the American ambassador to the UN won't help, and neither will the words of thanks from the Prime Minister's Office: This is a step that is nothing less than hostile to Israel. America, which Israel depends on more than ever, said yes to settlements. That is the one and only meaning of its decision, and in so doing, it supported the enterprise most damaging to Israel.

Moreover, it did so at a time when winds of change are blowing in the Middle East. A promise of change was heard from America, but instead, it continued with its automatic responses and its blind support of Israel's settlement building. This is not an America that will be able to change its standing among the peoples of the region. And Israel, an international pariah, once again found itself supported only by America.

This should have disturbed every Israeli. Is that what we are? Alone and condemned? And all for the continuation of that worthless enterprise? Is it really worth the price? To hell with the UN and the whole world is against us?

We can't wrap ourselves in this hollow iron dome forever. We must open our eyes and understand that if no country, aside from weakening America, supports this caprice of ours, then something fundamental is wrong here.

Israel, which is condemned by the entire world but continues merrily on its way, is a country that is losing its connection to reality. It is also a country that will ultimately find itself left entirely to its fate. That is why America's decision harmed Israel's interests: It continued to blind and stupefy Israel into thinking it can go on this way forever.

A friendly U.S., concerned for Israel's fate, should have said no. An America that understands that the settlements are the obstacle should have joined in condemning them. A superpower that wants to make peace, at a time when Arab peoples are rising up against their regimes and against the U.S. and Israel, should have understood that it must change the old, bad rules of the game of blanket support for the ally addicted to its settlements.

A friendly America should have mobilized to wean Israel of its addiction Only it can do so, and it should have started, belatedly, at the Security Council on Friday.

But promises of change and of real concern for Israel are one thing, and diplomatic behavior is another: another automatic veto, as if nothing has changed. Obama or George W. Bush, there's no difference. When Ambassador Susan Rice said that the draft resolution risked hardening the positions of both sides and could encourage the parties to refrain from negotiations, she misled. She knows that what prevents negotiations and hardens positions is continued building in the settlements.

And when the Israeli Foreign Ministry said it is "peculiar that the Security Council should choose to consider one single aspect" of Israeli-Palestinian negotiations "while ignoring the wider scope of events in our region," it, too, misled. Do the Foreign Ministry's spokesmen really believe there is a serious party that would agree to Israel creating irreversible facts on the ground without let or hindrance?

And to call this "one single aspect?" Perhaps it is only one, but it is certainly the most destructive. And thus it is the one the world sought to condemn - and rightly so.

Moreover, this veto was not cast during ordinary days. These are days of boiling lava in the region. If there were a responsible government in Israel, it would have stopped settlement building long ago - not only to deflect fire from Israel, but to promote an agreement that has never been more vital for it.

If the U.S. had been a responsible superpower, it would have voted for the resolution on Friday to rouse Israel from its dangerous sleep. Instead, we got a hostile veto from Washington, shouts of joy from Jerusalem and a party that will end very badly for both.